Pinning down the high impacts – LCA

Life Cycle Assessment – from birth till death & closing the loop

What’s the common thread tying Levis, Timberland, Coke, Starbucks, and Patagonia – besides being some of my favorite brands, they all are leading field in the sustainability space! They are forcing other businesses to dive deep into the supply chains in their product’s life cycle to identify the hidden environmental impacts which otherwise would’ve been over-ridden by assumptions.

Life cycle of a 501 Jean

LCA is a tool that gives a close to accurate ecological footprint of a product’s journey from cradle to grave, taking a systems thinking approach in its entirety and not just some selected part in isolation.

Here’s what these iconic brands discovered

Levis figured out after doing a complete LCA map of their pair of 501 jeans that the maximum  impact is in the consumer care, and not in the manufacturing processes, contrary to their assumption. 58% of its carbon footprint came from washing and drying jeans at home! However, the other big impact came at the other extreme – cotton growing, the most unsustainable form of agriculture.

(Cotton fields are dead zones – nothing grows and lives there except cotton, due to the humungous amounts of pesticides and toxics used in its plantation besides consuming loads of water)

Starbucks Coffee, after performing an LCA, found that 208 liters of water go into making one Grande sized Latte – 1/3rd of it used up in making milk and 2/3rd used up in coffee growing.

Patagonia’s LCA map revealed that a S-sized Patagonia cotton Tee uses more than 700 liters of water.

Coke’s one of the high areas of concern is water usage. 1 liter of Coke uses 1.9 liters of water.

Timberland’s carbon mapping showed that its maximum impact comes from the leather and PVC used in making shoes and the VOC (Volatile organic compound) based toxic adhesive used to glue the leather together.

Stonyfield Farm’s 42% emissions come from an unusual place – cows burps!

So, what’s the story behind? LCA locates the exact area of highest carbon impact, which enables designers to find long term sustainable solutions to these challenges.

Benefits of LCA

And that has led to Starbucks forming its CAFÉ code of conduct that works with farmers using the best coffee growing practices like the “Shade growing coffee’.

Cokes Reduce, Recycle, Replenish water project

It has led Coke to innovate in water usage such as air- jet cleaning instead of water-jet cleaning, thus reducing it’s per liter Coke-water consumption. It has led Patagonia to move from industrial to organic cotton and led Levis to support sustainably grown cotton and repurpose the jean into housing insulation at its end-of-life. It has led Timberland to track down the farm where the animal grazed under humane conditions before ending up as a shoe. It also led to developing water based resin and an alternate to PVC, for its shoes.The most prevalent example of an LCA is the impact of a vehicle. 80% of the CO2 emissions come at the running stage of a car – when it is with the consumer.

LCA of an efficient WagonR

Understanding LCA

In simple terms, LCA brings to fore the actual quantification of the resources that went into the factory at one end – energy, water, virgin materials and what came out of the factory at the other – emissions to land, water and air along with the packaged product.

LCA is about getting beyond to what you control. The thing to understand is that its not about maximizing one issue but about optimizing several simultaneously.

No single company controls more than 15% of the total impacts associated with their products – most of it is in either upstream or downstream phases. Using LCA, highly energy intensive processes and materials emerge giving companies the opportunity to design and innovate in ways  that’ll reduce those impacts.

Related articles:

Images LCA of a Jean taken from http://www.levistrauss.com/sustainability/product/life-cycle-jean

LCA of WagonR taken from Suzuki Environmental Report 2009

Home page LCA image – Interface Carpets @ http://www.interfaceglobal.com/

If you benefited from this post, I’d be very grateful if you’d help it spread by emailing it to your friends or share via links below on Twitter or Facebook. Thank you!

Advertisements

Comments

  1. Re: pinning down the high impacts LCA.
    I find it interesting that all the examples given are from manufacture of discretionary consumer goods (clothing and coffee/coke) or carmaking. Both of these sectors have fierce marketing pressures. It appears that these companies have put LCA in place as a means to differentiate their product and standout from the pack. This is a good result for the environment, but ultimately if consumers don’t reward the companies who choose to go down this route, by buying their products, it may just turn out to be a brief marketing fad. So (if you feel compelled to buy discretionary items that you don’t really need) you want to encourage more companies to conduct LCA you have to become an active consumer and support those products that have been subject to a full LCA.

    • Dear Peter

      Thanks for your observation. You are right in that LCA can be used as a differentiation strategy or as a matter of fact, the whole sustainability thinking can be a differentiator. However, I’ve always beleived that a consumer, though well informed, will always be ignorant of what to buy and what not to.
      It is the job of the business to promote sustainable or unsustainable consumption (LCA included). Whatever products these businesses throw in the market and create a demand for, will eventually be rewarded by the consumer. The eternal question is:
      How can a consumer know what to buy? A business or a company or media always tells him that. And if LCA or any sustainable practice is well marketed, then that is what the consumer will buy.

      I’m not negating consumer pressure – it is important, but businesses need to lead to create a market for greener products.

Trackbacks

  1. […] need compatible products that can sustain their entire lifecycle in the eco-system it lives in. If we are to move in the right direction at a brisk enough pace, then […]

  2. […] a LEED certified store, using recyclable/recycled paper cups, using least energy in the store, performing an LCA (life cycle assessment) and finding out the highest area of impact and working to reduce that […]

Comments (moderated)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.